Both are high quality sources of energy. Both have won the trust of millions of homes around America. Both come with their share of merits and flaws. So, which one should you be deciding on? At Boyle Energy, we have seen many of our customers struggle with this issue and we believe the more information you have at your disposal, the easier it becomes to arrive at a solution. Here’s a read that will give you both sides of the story as far as two of America’s most popular fuels are concerned.
Propane heating: Pros
1. More economical
Gallon to gallon, propane is less expensive than heating oil.
2. Efficient in operation
Propane furnaces are able to achieve much higher efficiency levels than heating oil furnaces. A propane furnace therefore, will provide more heat per gallon to your home.
3. No mess to clean up
Since propane is a clean burning fuel, it doesn’t lead to soot accumulation inside the furnace. The maintenance of propane furnaces as a result, is simpler and quicker than oil furnaces.
4. Clean burning fuel
Propane is the second cleanest burning fuel on the planet and produces less CO2 per gallon as compared to heating oil.
5. Non-toxic in nature
Propane leaks don’t contaminate groundwater or soil as it’s nontoxic and non-poisonous. This means propane tanks can be safely buried without the fear of health risks.
6. Powers almost anything
Unlike oil, propane can be used in a range of appliances like stoves, ovens, barbeques, refrigerators and even cars and other vehicles.
7. Stores more
Propane tanks have larger capacities than heating oil tanks which translates into fewer deliveries and room for ‘stock ups’ during times when propane prices hit their lows.
Propane heating: Cons
1. Higher equipment cost
Propane burning equipment comes with a higher purchase cost than oil-based systems.
2. Combustible by nature
Propane and air do not make a safe combination and so precautions are needed to ensure safe operation of the equipment.
Oil heating: Pros
1. Greater output
Heating oil has a higher BTU output per gallon (137,000 BTUs /gallon as compared to propane’s 91,000 /gallon). This means heating oil results in greater energy output when used for heating.
2. Lower heating cost
Heating oil gets used up more slowly than propane. So, even if the per gallon cost of propane is less, you would have to pay less to heat your house with heating oil.
3. Easier to purchase
Purchasing heating oil equipment will mean a lower upfront cost than going in for propane based equipment.
Oil heating: Cons
1. Possibility of leaks
One disadvantage of heating oil tanks is they are susceptible to leaks which could lead to a costly expense that is often not covered by the homeowner’s insurance
2. Unpredictable pricing
Because a major supply of heating oil comes from offshore sources, its prices are subject to international market trends. This brings a higher degree of volatility in the pricing of heating oil as compared to propane.
3. More emissions
Heating oil produces a significantly higher amount of carbon dioxide than propane.
4. Higher maintenance
Oil furnaces need to be cleaned more frequently than propane furnaces, which means higher maintenance costs.
It’s a tricky situation deciding between heating oil and propane, because they both come with their share of good and not so good. At Boyle Energy, we believe decisions such as this are subjective and vary from household to household; so we do hope you will use the information in this article to arrive at the choice that perfectly matches your home’s needs as well as your budget. If you’re interested in heating oil companies in Delaware, propane companies in Philadelphia PA, propane heating companies near you or would like to know the price of heating oil in Philadelphia PA, feel free to give us a call. At Boyle Energy, we’ve been serving multiple neighbourhoods with both propane and heating oil deliveries as well as maintenance and tune-up services since 1937. We’d be happy to welcome you into the Boyle family of customers who rely on our quality, integrity and affordability.